Clicky

93 Responses to “Time to Play: What’s in YOUR Soap?”

Comments

Read below or add a comment...

  1. John Williams

    What is proven about commercial tallowates to be negative just because the cattle may have been injected with antibiotics and so forth? Do these animal drugs find their way into commercial tallowates? What is the refining process for animal tallow? I would like to know more before I can justify $3.25 for a bar of Dr. Bronners. In any case, there are “white label” brands such as Dr. Organics that are far cheaper than Dr. Bronners and equally as pure and effective.

  2. David

    I am vegetarian but seriously the bar soaps are that are tallow-free are far too expensive! Who but the upper middle class professional with a great job can afford $3 a bar soaps? What we need is a good mass produced vegie/vegan soap that’s affordable.

    • David, as a soap maker myself I can assure you that the $3 bar of real soap will, if it’s made well, last far longer and be far kinder to your skin than commercial soap. And you won’t need any other products to follow up with because the natural glycerine hasn’t been stripped from it. Oh, and I speak as a lower middle class mother of four in a single income family.

      • Well said Sarah! My only additional input is that $3 is extremely inexpensive for a good bar of soap. You can easily pay $20 for a good bar and save in the long run over other products you will no longer need, and your wellness in the long run because you are decreasing your toxin in take.

    • Bryan

      My homemade 2 and 3 oz soaps that I give away to my friends and family last one person a month and would sell on the market for $2. My 5 oz olive oil house cleaning soap that I also give to friends and family typically lasts 6 to 9 months and would retail for $5 if I sold it. Several years ago when I learned that I was bathing in cow fat I changed from Ivory to Gefen Kosher Soap which is just coconut oil, water and lye (they even have Caustic Soda listed as an ingredient). The 4 oz bars sell for $2.49 and would last over a month. When I went to my doctor a few weeks after starting to use the Gefen soap for a check up she commented that my skin looked better than my last visit and asked what I was using. So much for “gentle” Ivory!!!!!

  3. Carol Cameo

    I had used dove for years but it became WAY TOO PRICEY so i went back to the OLD bar soap Jergens …which is a mild soap gentle enough for a baby. But of course if U are a vegetarian AND the thought of soap containing animal products scares u then u might have to stick to some other soap……and BTW i used Kirks Castile soap and it burned and tingled my skin so bad i stopped using it.

    • Cass

      Yeah, because it’s too alkaline. People simply do not understand they are victims of the cosmetic industry “green washing” them.
      If honey were a good face cleanser, they would not have invented BAR SOAP thousands of years ago. Today’s Sydnet bars are far better for your skin and heads up…who gives a sweet fiddlers fuck if the tallow came from a grass fed cow?
      You don’t need to eat your facial cleanser. That’s the most ridiculous notion of all.
      Women are just stupid.

  4. Julie

    People…we don’t put garbage in our body, why put it on your body?

  5. I just discovered the EWG website and this makes me very glad I make my own laundry detergent. I am with you concerning the production of these inexpensive bath bars containing all the mystery ingredients. I’m wondering about health and sanitation regarding the collection of the animal fats in question too. Sure it’s on a super gigantic scale so I dare not think of all this fat being processed! Anyway bottom line, I’m trying to find a new bar soap to use to replace Zote and Fels Naptha in my laundry detergent . I’ve thought of using Zum,Toms, or the round soaps thatare that come in bulk without packaging, these can be purchased at Whole Foods or Natural Grocers. I’m willing to pay a little more to protect the health of my family. Also Kirks Castile is another option. I’m going to continue my research in the meantime.

    • Abhi Tambar

      Is it possible to have a legislation which make it compulsory for the manufacturer to declare the component or ingredients i.e. animal fat or plant oil & to be more specific which animal or plant bases and in what ratio.

  6. Zee Bee

    Its this kind of mongering and misinformation that is frustrating ! Syndet bars like Dove are not soaps made of lye !They contain mild surfactants like isethionate,…this makes them milder than traditional soaps.
    Tallow is a fat just like palm oil is ,once saponified it changes completely leaving behind no ‘animalness’.once animals are slaughtered for food purposes its a by product used for years !oils like coconut,palm olive require resources like land,water!How sustainable is that ?
    The idea should be to use what’s easily available locally ,preferably cheap so prices can be kept down !That is lesser carbon footprint too !
    Being environmentally savvy,organic etc doesn’t mean hauling of resources from third world countries and waste feul !

  7. Jessica

    I think you’re missing the point. Buying soap like Dove and Ivory supports animal cruelty if the tallow comes from confined and mistreated animals. Sure, the animal is dead and I’m all for not wasting what can be used, but if demand continues to be high for products that come from these abused animals, then they’ll continue to be abused for the supply.

    I use Dr. Bronner’s Castile Soap for nearly everything (shower soap, face wash, shampoo, laundry detergent, general purpose cleaner…). I dilute it a lot and a $15 bottle can go a LONG way.

  8. I’m all for using the whole animal! There’s nothing wrong with tallow based bar soap if it comes from humanely raised animals and doesn’t contain a lot of other synthetic junk. Unfortunately, that can be hard to find, especially in your cheap commercial soaps. Enter A Wild Soap Bar. They’re made with 100% certified organic vegetable oils and only safe, natural ingredients. Yep, they’re expensive, but that’s because they’re handmade in the USA with high quality ingredients by skilled artisans who earn a living wage. You get what you pay for. Nuff said.

    • Cass

      Yeah…I’ve had that nasty organic bar crap. Do you understand pH? Because that soap is as alkaline as Dishsoap. There are clean labs in the world that FORMULATE products that are safe, and if they are not, they fix the fucking problem. Hipsters are stupid. I’m getting that on a tshirt. Enjoy your acne, losers

  9. Cass

    I a, so tired of this crunchy movement and the greenwashing bullshit. There is NOTHING wrong with dove soap. You have all been baited and reeled in by the Greenwash of the beauty industry.

  10. apple

    i feel slightly awake to the fact that my dove soap isnt as wonderful as i thought it was all these years. today just being curious about what was in my bar of soap, im surprised. I would rather have more natural ingredients in my bar of soap. Thanks for the information.

  11. Sarah

    I have more of a problem with the chemicals used in these mass produced “soaps.” These “soaps” are not even classified by the FDA as soap, they are classified as cosmetics because they cleanse using detergents. A true soap is the resulting ‘salt’ after the chemical reaction between lye and a fat.

    The worst thing about these mass produced ‘soaps’ is that many of the ingredients used in them are carcinogenic or toxic. I’m not lying about the carcinogens. Just research MSDS (the name of the ingredient). Look at section 11. MSDS sheets tell it like it is. As a cancer survivor (who is still battling cancer 12+ years post surgery), who has lost many family members to cancer, I have a real problem with cleaning my skin with toxins.

    Nobody would ever consider eating most of the chemicals in those soaps if they were mixed into food, so why would anybody put that stuff on their skin? The skin absorbs what is put on it. Not only that, but nobody would ever consider washing themselves with liquid laundry detergent, but in all reality that is what people are doing when they use cheap mass produced soap.

    If paying $3 for a bar of soap seems insane, try making your own. It is fun, and fascinating to learn how oils work together to create an amazing bar of soap. After making your own, you might even realize why artisans charge so much for fancy, handcrafted soaps. And most importantly: Your skin will thank you for it!

leave a crunchy comment ...