Clicky

  • Melody

    I just finished making the deodorant now. I don’t know why I didn’t think of it before, but the green clay that I bought made my deodorant green (of course)! I don’t mind it so much but I don’t think my family and friends who will be receiving them as gifts would mind a tad bit. Next time I will be using a clay that isn’t green!

  • kevin

    thanks for the “secret.” i made my own receipe the other day with tea tree oil and baking soda and acid water for a spray on version, but I like your bar version too.

    i’m curious what you think of using bentonite clay since it is known to absorb toxins?

  • http://www.aubynstafford.net Aubyn

    I want to do this, but until I have enough bucks to get all the ingredients together (a little broke right now) I do this. You know that Burt’s Bees lip balm that kind of has the right idea but still isn’t crunchy enough? I got an old tin of that (not the tube, the flat tin thing, although any container would work) and put some baking soda in it, then dropped in enough eucalyptus essential oil to saturate it. I just take a little dab on my finger and rub it in my pits! It provides a wonderful cooling sensation and all-day stink defense. Not right after shaving, though. It gets a little burn-y that way. Fortunately I only shave about once a month. :)

  • Joy

    It sounds like it’s worth a try. I stopped using the aluminum deodorants many, many years ago. Right now I use Lafe’s Natural Organic spray deodorant and it has worked for me for about 10 years. Those first 4 years of it in Texas hot summers and I really love it. When I’m just about out, I’ll give this homemade one a try. Thanks.

  • Kristina

    Ooooh, I reeeeeealllly wanna try this! Need to shop for all those ingredients though, so I may get them a bit at a time and make it down the line. I am saving my old container for this verrrry purpose!

    Right now I am using something from LUSH that is, well, as far as I can tell, all natural. It’s a solid bar that looks something like that that you rub on your pits. Then for extra protection and scent I use another of their deodorants that is a powder (coconut based and scented). The stinky part (pardon pun) is I have to shake it into my hand and apply it by rubbing, which gets messy.

    It works well, better than the old stuff I used to use, and doesn’t like get stuck in my pores. I could never get that commercial stuff OFF my skin!

  • Patricia

    I’ve been using a very similar recipe for quite some time now, but I’ve noticed the coconut oil leaves oil stains in the arm pits of my shirts; I’m now on the hunt for something to substitute it with.

    Any ideas?

  • Heffalumpy

    I haven’t read all the comments yet, but couldn’t the toilet paper tube be lined with a roll of waxed paper? That should stop the seepage… especially if the wp over-lap is folded/crimped a couple of times.

  • jane

    I’m too lazy to make my own, too cheap to buy the natural ones. The “regular” ones worked just fine until I got pregnant, I’ve no idea what happened to my body, but I was stinky ALL DAY LONG. Then I read somewhere (I think it was in the “People’s Pharmacy”) about Milk of Magnesium. I’m never buying “regular” deodorant again.
    MoM is cheap, easy, works and doesn’t go bad.

    • Lauren @ DessertsByLauren.com

      THANK YOU so much for posting this!  I have already made about 4 different recipes.  The ones with the baking soda burn me, the ones without them just don’t work.  I remembered reading your comment yesterday while I was in CVS and decided to give the MoM a try.  It was like $2 for a small bottle which could probably last months.  Tried it today and I have to say I’m shocked at how well it worked!  I already told a few of my friends about it.  Thank you, thank you, thank you!!!!!!

      • http://www.crunchybetty.com CrunchyBetty

        Hey lady. Will you do me a favor and tell me the ingredients in your milk of magnesia? I’ve been doing some research on it over the last few weeks, and I’m pretty sure it contains aluminum hydroxide. Whether or not that’s one of the “leachable” forms of aluminum, though, I don’t know. I’m just curious if yours has it in there – and if it doesn’t, whether or not it still works. ‘Cause it might be the aluminum that’s doing the deo duty.

        • heymomheymom

          The original only has   Magnesium hydroxide, purified water, sodium hypochlorite (according to the phillips website)

          • Jennifer

            “Sodium hypochlorite solution, commonly known as bleach or chlorox, is frequently used as a disinfectant or a bleaching agent.”

            So, uh .. you’re putting bleach on your armpits which I imagine is just as bad as aluminum.  O_o

          • Jennifer

            “Sodium hypochlorite solution, commonly known as bleach or chlorox, is frequently used as a disinfectant or a bleaching agent.”

            So, uh .. you’re putting bleach on your armpits which I imagine is just as bad as aluminum.  O_o

  • Daisy

    For anyone who is sensitive to corn (or isn’t down with GMO), you can use arrowroot powder instead of cornstarch.

    Patricia, coconut oil is antibacterial which is why it’s perfect for deodorant. Maybe apply a thinner layer or decrease the amount slightly? If that doesn’t work, you could try increasing the shea butter and adding coconut powder.

  • Bree

    Has anyone found a way around the use of the plastic container. It seems to me that when the one wears out you would have to buy a stick of regular deodorant (or find a supplier of just the container) and remove the old deodorant and throw it out. Is there an alternative to the cheap plastic?

    • Lauren

      I actually use a small mason jar and scratch it off with the back of my finger nail and roll it into a ball.  It kinda melts with your body heat.  

  • JO

    WHAT KIND OF CLAY?
    WHERE CAN I BUY IT? The type you use for ART PROJECTS?

    Where can i buy beeswax?

  • Jocelyn

    Jo you can order clay and beeswax off http://www.mountainroseherbs.com. Also, http://www.tkbtrading.com. I have also bought clay from a local herb shop.

  • http://korirockwell.blogspot.com/ Kori

    http://www.etsy.com sells LOTS of different, empty containers. Simply search “container”, or you can be more specific by searching “lip balm container”, or even “deodorant container”. I just did this and found perfect stuff.

  • Krissy

    I thought we were supposed to avoid aluminum. Here is the mineral content of bentonite clay according the mountain rose herbs website:

    Mineral Content
    Silica- 61.4%
    Aluminum- 18.1%
    Iron- 3.5%
    Sodium- 2.3%
    Magnesium- 1.7%
    Calcium- 0.04%
    Titanium- 0.02%
    Potassium- 0.01%
    Moisture- 7.8%
    pH – 8.3 – 9.1

  • Krissy

    I just read in my Nourishing Traditions book that “Clay also contains aluminum, but silicon, present in large amounts in all clays, prevents absorption of this toxic metal and actually helps the body eliminate aluminum that is bound in the tissues.”

    I guess I answered my own question :)

  • Shallee

    I am so gonna try this recipe and reading Kori’s and Krissy’s comment really helps see how practical this is.

  • rockellea

    I am looking for an alternative to brand deodorant. I have read a lot of people using straight milk of magnesia and others using straight baking soda… Has anyone tried this? And if the do work so well by themselves – wouldn’t they be a dynamic duo to mix together? And have any of you tried that?

  • Dennis

    um…bentonite clay has aluminum in it…lots of it.

    • http://www.crunchybetty.com CrunchyBetty

      Ahhhh …. I’m going to have to do an actual post about this because I keep getting this comment.

      It’s my understanding that the aluminum found in bentonite (and pretty much any other clay) is a vastly different structure than man-made synthetic aluminums found in store-bought deodorant. Mostly, it is far too large of a molecule for your body to absorb. It stays on the skin and kills the bacteria there, but it does not absorb into the body.

      • Anonymouse

        Aluminum does NOT kill bacteria. It blocks pores.
        Elemental aluminum CAN be absorbed via bodily acids.

        • http://www.crunchybetty.com CrunchyBetty

          I would really, really, really love to see the research that shows that aluminum silicate leaches into the skin. Everything I’ve read has either been pure speculation or completely negating that it does and could.

          http://curezone.com/forums/fm.asp?i=570441

          That given, the amount of information I can find by directly searching (which I have repeatedly, for hours, at least once every two weeks) is still incredibly contradictory.

          In light of that, I’ve just reached out to the two people I know who’ll either be able to answer the issue definitively – or tell me that no one knows for sure at this point. When I hear back from them, I’ll post a full report on the blog. :)

  • Kate

    I’m so glad I found this! Both me and my sister are quite sensitive to baking soda. Baking soda in household things (particularly laundry soap) always leaves my skin super itchy, and thus has made me reluctant to put it in anything that touches my body. And my sis – oh dear. She was using a baking soda deodorant for a while and it got to the point where it pretty much burned a layer of her skin off (she was THAT determined to not use commercial deodorant). She still tries to pretend she’s not really affected by it, so I’m psyched to show her this. Because maybe, just maybe, she can stop trying to burn off her pores.

  • Lauren @DessertsByLauren.com

    I started using just a little baking soda with cornstarch and coconut oil with a few drops of lavender.  LOVE it!  I may have to try out this recipe when I run out.  I love making my own.  It works so much better for me.  

  • http://twitter.com/korirockwell Kori Rockwell

    I filled empty deodorant containers with this mixture, but the only thing is that it melts. I have to keep it in the fridge to be able to use it. But other than that, I love it! My under arms rarely itch anymore and I NEVER smell myself. It’s wonderful, thank you!

    I’m going to add more beeswax and see if that fixes the melting.

    • Jennmnoble

      I am having the same problem with melting.  It also leaks through the bottom of my deodorant container and makes a huge mess. 

      Did you get a chance to try it with more beeswax?  Did that make a difference?

  • Kyla Rieger

    To the people having trouble with coconut oil staining your shirts: don’t put your clothes on directly after applying the deodorant. Give your pits about 5 minutes to absorb the oil, use a dry washcloth to brush off any clumps that may be left behind (I currently use a baking soda/cornstarch/coconut oil deo– it leaves clumps. I’m looking forward to trying this Crunchy Betty recipe!), and then put your shirts on with confidence. For the clothes that already have oil stains on them, rub a couple of drops of dish soap into the stains before tossing them in your washing machine and wash with hot water. Coconut oil stains are a blessing, really. I have tons of t-shirts that have greasy armpit stains from commercial deodorant, and that stuff doesn’t come out!   

  • Yippy4Skippy

    Just made this and it is cooling in the freezer! I subbed out the clay for 3 tsp. arrowroot powder and 1 tsp. bakind soda since that’s what I had.  Hope this works!

  • Lauren @ DessertsByLauren.com

    Just made this with arrowroot in place of the clay.  I can’t wait to try it tomorrow.  The baking soda ones burn me so bad and I just bought some Tom’s of Main for my husband (since he’s totally against the home made one for some reason) and it just doesn’t work on me.  I stink within like 3 hours.  

    • Lauren @ DessertsByLauren.com

      Oh, but the baking soda one I’ve re-named “Foot Funk” because it works great on my feet!  No stink, and makes my feet nice and soft!  

  • Lauren @ DessertsByLauren.com

    Ok, after 1 day i’m sad to say that this did not work for me.  I showered, put it on, went to the grocery store and on the checkout line I caught a whiff of myself.  I STINK!  Came home, washed off, re-applied hoping it was a fluke.  A few hours later and again… I stink!  I wish the baking soda didn’t burn me raw.  :(  Any suggestions? 

    • http://twitter.com/dongbanger dongbanger.com

      Maybe using too much baking soda is the problem?? IDK.  I saw some recipe online that called for 1/4cup baking soda! Woah! That seems like way too much b/c baking soda has the scratchy quality to it.  Maybe try 1 or 2 TBSP? Or maybe as little as 2tsp?

  • Elisa

    Is there anything I can substitute for coconut oil? I made your original recipe and loved it, but it stained ALL my shirts (I sweat a lot). So I had to stop using it. But I’d love to try this.

  • Kate

    I switched from clinical strength Secret to Tom’s all natural deodorant, and I am looking into making my own.  I love that this recipe has shea butter in it.  I wax and find that having some type of moisturizer goes well with waxing.  The waxing ensures my skin is smooth and the moisturizer ensures my skin remains soft.  Thank you for this post!!! 

    • Lauren @ DessertsByLauren.com

      Tom’s has aluminum in it, so if you’re using it to stay away from aluminum, look elsewhere.  That’s why I bought it, and then I found out that “potassium alum” is another name for aluminum.  

      • Ms. Sweden

        Potassium alum is not a chemical though. Huge difference. Potassium Alum is a completely natural mineral salt derived from the
        earth. It is one of the most abundant substances on earth, just behind oxygen
        and silicon. It’s in the air we breathe, the water we drink, the foods we eat
        and is one of the basic building blocks of our environment. Natural deodorants such as those of Naturally Fresh Deodorant Crystal products are COMPLETELY safe.

        Make no mistake; alum is a natural compound, compared to conventional deodorants/antiperspirants which contain processed aluminum.

  • http://twitter.com/dongbanger dongbanger.com

    I think the recipe would be super awesome if you used cocoa butter instead of beeswax. Cocoa butter is great for conditioning/toning the delicate skin area (i try to use it under there as often as possible). Maybe a 1TBSP of baking soda? Ooo, I need to try to make this too. :P

  • Haileyhunt

    Recently made my own with coconut oil, corn starch and baking soda! Love it so far but I definitely want to try this one.

  • http://www.naturallyfreshdeodorantcrystal.com/ Natural deodorant

    Hi…

    I read your post and really you have done a great effort, I
    think its one of the best deodorant but I have something to recommend you to
    use the same thing “Deodorant” I visit many sites and blogs most of the
    deodorant I like but the problem is they are not satisfy me but at last I visit
    this site
    when I visit this then I feel  this product give me that service which satisfied
    me at every aspects of the product that’s why I said to all of u to use this
    and feel the differences.

    Thanks

  • Kay

    You are my new favourite person.  I am sending you cookies. And a medal. And then some more cookies. Thank you!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Leigha-May/620484116 Leigha May

    so…i just finished making my first batch. and it’s GRAY. not light gray, like muddy pewter gray. i know it was the bentonite clay that did it, because immediately after adding that, the color got all mucked up. now, i will still give this a shot (although, i’m worried about it staining clothes), but i know my boyfriend will be immediately scared away. what do i do?! i used the bentonite made by NOW (which was not an easy thing to find) – any replacements?! i was hoping to include jars of these in my homemade beauty baskets for christmas (yes, which i did JUST start 6 days before) , but am reluctant to gift gray deodorant. help?!

    • Amanda J.

       Bentonite clay recipe doesn’t stain most clothes, but DOES leave color (muddy green, for me) behind until washed. The color wasn’t a huge turnoff to me. But I’ve given this recipe 3 weeks now, and I’m stinkier than EVER before. Back to the regular coconut oil, baking soda recipe!

  • Mrsdestinylibra

    I stink bad, like total BO smell.  Will this recipe work for me? Is there a must use ingredient to help with that god awful smell?  I have no luck with over the counter “deodorants” making or stopping that odor. Toms is no match for me either. I had decided the antiperspirant is the key ingredient yet some OTC “antiperspirant + deodorants” work better than others for me.

    • Lica

      I talked to one girl, she is very sensitive to everything, so she decided to experiment. She tried to use just almond oil, nothing else, she said she found a miracle that helps to stop stinky situation and there is absolutely no irritation. Try it, if this doesn’t work, you still can use this oil as a hair mask a couple of times a week.

  • http://gratefulforgrace.com/ Grateful for Grace

    Ok, so I know this was posted months ago… but I just found it via Pinterest.  I have pretty much given up on natural deodorants.  I keep being stinky.  I am going to give this a go though and you have me hopeful.  Will check in.  

  • Mongoose

    Any updates regarding cornstarch or arrowroot powder results?  I started with the 50/50 Baking Soda (BS) w/ coconut recipe but got a terrible rash. (Bob Mill’s aluminum free version) I reduced BS to CS ratio so that it still worked but without so much grittiness/rash – but it ended up having a lot of crumble-factor. I use the BS because I think I need the extra protection to last until 7pm at the gym ;)

    I recently found your version above and hoped that the addition of shea and beeswax would improve the texture -making it sticky enough to stick to my skin and not leave a mess on the bathroom floor (or in my shirt sleeve). However, I’m finding that using 4 tsp of cornstarch (instead of clay) is still REALLY pasty soft.  I’ve resorted to adding a tsp of BS then a few tsp of CS until I get a “solid”.  But I’ve been lazy about noting exact measurements ;)   

    Has anyone else has experimented with the cornstarch and found a winner ratio that will work in a deodorant container without being too dry/hard (crumbles) or too soft (going to goo with body heat). 

    I’d try it without BS but it still seems like the recipe above is really, really soft (maybe clay absorbs WAY more?)

    If I stumble upon a winning combo, I’ll be sure to share my findings! 

    PS Any tips for black tanks/little black dresses – I’m constantly dusting myself when I wear one of these LOL Is the cosmetic clay less dusty?

    • Lica

      Coconut oil is good, BUT it can cause a very bad irritation, especially on fresh shaved skin. It starts to itch really bad, and then the rash appears. So, you guys, need to be careful with some ingredients.  As for lavender, DO NOT use it at all. Lavender kills the skin cells.

      • Mongoose

        Fortunately, I haven’t had any trouble with coconut oil – I use it in the bath, on skin, on hair overnight, in brownies (LOL) and found it works wonderfully.

        But, I had no idea about the lavender – its always been promoted as being soothing for bug bites, etc.  I have heard about TT being implicated in weird hormone stuff w/ teen boys growing “breasts”.  Still I usually add some TT, Lav, and Sweet orange (about 5 drops of each) into what amounts to a cup or so of this base deo mix. 

        Do you know much about rosemary?  I love that fragrance as well, so much so that I bring in bunches from the yard as an air freshener :) Maybe I should sub it in place of the others.

      • rosebriars

        Sounds like you’re allergic to coconut oil. I’m intrigued by your lavender comment, my EO book lists it as an excellent oil for skin uses safe without dilution, and I have myriad personal experiences with its amazing healing powers when used topically. There is no mention of any possible skin issues. Cinnamon oil, on the other hand, is caustic and “repeated use can result in extreme contact sensitization.”
        As with anything we put in or on our bodies we should stop use if we see adverse reactions but we also need to do research and guard against spreading myths.

  • Plrubley

    Clay, bentonite if fact has aluminum. Your better off with cornstarch.
    My daughter made this and used baking soda. She love it.
    Remember when working with clays you are using minerals. Aluminum, and other metals are in clay, dirt rock ect.
    I am going to try this with the corn starch and a little baking soda!
    Thank you for a great recipe.

  • Hailey

    I first tried this recipe as is, but with cornstarch as I did not have any clay on hand.
    It worked, but not as well as the BS/CS/CO one. I found this too soft and messy and not as absorbent. Last night, I used 3 Tbsp of beeswax and used kaolin clay instead of the cornstarch. Seems to be a much thicker consistency but still not as solid as I would like. I’m hoping the clay helps with smell better! If this is a big improvement I think I will add another Tbs of beeswax and  2 Tsp of clay for my next one!

    I was wondering if you ever heard back from the people you asked regarding the aluminum in clay?

    Thanks for the awesome posts!

  • Xoxo3106

    I was wondering if it is safe to make this in an everyday pan? Like the same ones I use to make soup? Or should I just designate a pan to this? Just wanna make sure I’m not hurting the fam by making soup in a pot which I cooked these ingredients in. Thank you :)

    • Gertrude

      Given all the ingredients, it would probably just clean your pan really well. I wouldn’t worry about hurting anyone. Besides, every ingredient is edible.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Robin-Turner/100000919634537 Robin Turner

    wow, lots of discussion on aluminum.  If there’s any knowledge of Chemistry here then there’s must be a realization that first Aluminum in and of itself is not harmful except in high quantities as is any mineral or metal. (such as iron) second, the aluminum used in antiperspirant is NOT the same as the aluminum found in our natural environment.  Our natural Aluminum is identified on the Elemental Table as Al. Simple, unadulterated aluminum (found in clay).  THIS is the molecular formula for Aluminum zirconium tetrachlorohydrex gly (whish is found in your OTC Antiperspirant) AlyZr(OH)3y+4-xClxmGly·nH2O.  This is NOT in your clay.

  • Amanda

    I have recently been changing a lot in my diet of what I put into it and onto it. I am a vegetarian working on vegan. And eat no processed foods, mostly whole. 10 yrs ago, I really had bad sweating problems that started when I was a late teen and continued through 20′s.

    So I got some super deodorant, cant remember the name but it was potent, and burned like no other and itched!! But it dried my sweat up completely, and I started to wonder if that was good for my body, cause it was toxins that needed to come out or go somewhere.

    I started noticing my left arm hurting/achey all the time but blew it off as the way I was perhaps sleeping on it. 9 Months later, after I had since stopped using the deodorant..I felt a lump. I was 22.( I am cancer free and 33 now). Needless to say it was a Synovial Sarcoma Tumor. I had cancer. They said it was extremely rare and had no known cause. To this day, I believe it was caused from those toxins being trapped in my system. The tumor was about the size of a golf ball once taken out, not too fr down from my armpit and 2 lymph nodes were taken from under the armpit as well.

    I had later heard from a friend of someone she knows who got same thing, same place, after using same product. Is alluminum safe? Hmmmm

    Now I am using natural stuff as much as possible. Toothpaste, lotions, shampoo, conditioner, now I have to try this. But I still have problems with sweating at times and can only smell fresh with using “secret”. Now I will have to try “no secret”.

    Thank you for your site, the world and its chemicals are giving us all cancer.

  • Kim

    I’ve been using this DO recipe for a month or so now, most days it works great! But I am about to have a baby and wonder about the safety of the essential oils getting in my breastmilk…does anyone know if these oils are ok for babies in breastmilk? Or are there safe substitutes to switch with? I appreciate any insight, thanks!

    • rosebriars

      I use essential oils daily while nursing without problems. I would say if you’re concerned avoid any that shouldn’t be taken internally (wintergreen for example) and don’t use peppermint until nursing is well established as it can reduce milk supply. Tea tree (also called malaleuca) and Rosemary should be fine.

  • hammouse

    i use Naturally fresh roll on. i really love the chamomile and green tea flavour

  • Joanna Gonzalez

    im making mine now and it is SO DARK My clay was grey?? you think it will matter?
     

Wp Plugin by capn3m0